Review: Cygnet Theatre's 'Follies' Nostalgically Honors Past and Present

A New Beginning for The Joan and a Revival of “Follies”

The 1971 musical “Follies” brings together a group of retired performers who reunite for one night at a once-thriving Broadway theater that has long since fallen into disrepair. This poignant story of nostalgia, regret, and the passage of time now finds a new home at The Joan, a state-of-the-art theater complex in San Diego. The choice to open Cygnet Theatre’s first season with this rarely performed show might seem surprising, but it perfectly aligns with the spirit of The Joan itself.

Built over the past two years within the remnants of a shuttered U.S. Navy building that had stood empty for more than three decades, The Joan represents a rebirth. Just as the Weismann Theater in “Follies” is resurrected in a dream sequence, The Joan emerges as a vibrant cultural hub. The Joseph Clayes III Theater, where the production takes place, features a proscenium stage that mirrors the grandeur of the original Weismann Theater. The iconic red curtains, adorned with Cygnet Theatre’s swan logo, serve as a symbolic bridge between the past and present.

The Joan offers more than just a performance space. Its public areas are modern and sleek, featuring a spacious women's restroom and an art gallery that enhances the overall experience. The Joseph Clayes III Theater is designed with comfort and functionality in mind, offering excellent sightlines, advanced lighting and sound systems, and a large stage that accommodates both intimate and grand performances. Outdoor seating and covered walkways add to the appeal, while nearby parking and dining options make it a convenient destination for theatergoers.

Cygnet Artistic Director Sean Murray directed “Follies” with a deep respect for the original concept, while also bringing a fresh perspective to the material. The cast includes veteran actors who have been part of San Diego’s theater scene for decades, adding a sense of authenticity and depth to the production. Notable performers include Leigh Scarritt, Ralph Johnson, Melinda Gilb, Patti Goodwin, and Anise Ritchie, each delivering compelling performances that highlight their extensive experience.

The set design by Andrew Hull captures the essence of a crumbling theater, with realistic details such as a disintegrating proscenium arch and gold-hued footlights. The narrative follows former showgirls, dancers, and singers from the 1920s through the 1940s as they gather for a reunion. Their interactions are filled with nostalgia, laughter, and moments of emotional reflection, culminating in a bittersweet farewell before the theater is demolished.

A central theme of the musical is the idea of “ghosts” — the younger versions of the characters who remain frozen in time, observing their older selves. Murray cleverly casts young actors who closely resemble their older counterparts, enhancing the magical realism of the production. This technique adds a layer of depth to the storytelling and reinforces the show’s exploration of memory and identity.

The four main characters — Sally and Buddy Plummer, and Ben and Phyllis Stone — form the heart of the story. Karole Foreman, David Humphrey, Sandy Campbell, and Russell Garrett deliver standout performances that anchor the narrative. Their portrayals of complex emotions and relationships bring the story to life, making it both engaging and emotionally resonant.

While the first act may feel slow as the characters reconnect and reminisce, the second act delivers powerful dramatic moments. The extended dream sequence known as “Loveland” showcases the romantic missteps of the characters in a series of nostalgic vignettes. These scenes, combined with the strong performances and creative direction, elevate the production and provide a satisfying conclusion.

“Follies” is a product of its time, and some elements may feel dated to modern audiences. However, the production at The Joan is a loving tribute to the original, with exceptional choreography, costumes, sound, and lighting. It is a must-see for theater enthusiasts and a testament to the transformative power of art.

Show Details

When:
7 p.m. Wednesdays through Fridays, 2 and 7 p.m. Saturdays, 2 p.m. Sundays. Through Oct. 12

Where:
Cygnet Theatre at The Joan, 2880 Roosevelt Road, Arts District Liberty Station, San Diego

Tickets:
$44 and up

Phone:
619-337-1525

Online:
cygnettheatre.com